CRTC investigating Norton for pushing crypto-mining software program

CRTC investigating Norton for pushing crypto-mining software program

At concern are allegations the corporate ‘put in, or prompted to be put in, Norton Crypto on the pc methods of a few of its Norton 360 prospects with out consent’

Article content material

OTTAWA — The CRTC is investigating main cybersecurity software program firm NortonLifeLock over whether or not it broke anti-spam legal guidelines when it put in a cryptocurrency-mining software program onto Canadians’ computer systems with out their “specific consent” in 2021.

Commercial 2

Article content material

In August, the CRTC launched an investigation into the American software program big, now referred to as Gen Digital, which owns the “Norton 360” cybersecurity program suite.

At concern are allegations that NortonLifeLock (NLL) “had put in, or prompted to be put in, Norton Crypto on the pc methods of a few of its Norton 360 prospects with out consent,” in line with a compliance settlement between the regulator and the corporate signed final month and obtained by the Nationwide Submit.

Norton Crypto was a controversial program launched by NortonLifeLock in July 2021 that turned customers’ computer systems into “low-volume” cryptocurrency mining machines when the system was idling. Cryptocurrency like bitcoin could be “mined” by computer systems performing advanced, time-consuming calculations that may unlock small quantities of forex. Norton Crypto customers stored the revenue, minus a 15 per cent fee to Norton.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

However customers and privateness watchers rapidly turned involved once they famous that the software program was mechanically downloaded as a part of the Norton 360 cybersecurity software program set up package deal.

The CRTC launched an investigation into the corporate final summer season as a result of it was involved that the corporate was putting in the crypto program with out customers’ knowledgeable consent, thus breaking the spyware and adware sections of Canada’s anti-spam laws.

The laws “prohibits the set up of a pc program (software program) to a different individual’s computing system (e.g., laptop computer, smartphone, desktop, gaming console or different linked system) in the midst of business exercise with out the specific consent of the system proprietor or a certified person,” in line with the CRTC’s web site.

Commercial 4

Article content material

Within the weeks following the launch of the investigation, and with NLL already underneath fireplace within the U.S. due to Norton Crypto, the corporate advised the CRTC it wished an “early decision of the investigation.”

The corporate admitted that Norton Crypto was “downloaded as a part of the Norton 360 set up package deal, and put in concurrently Norton 360,” in line with the settlement.

However in each the settlement and an announcement offered Monday, the corporate — now named Gen — denied it had damaged any legal guidelines and argued that purchasers all the time needed to “choose in” to make use of the crypto service.

“Gen takes compliance with all legal guidelines and rules extraordinarily significantly and voluntarily prolonged its full cooperation to the CRTC. We reiterate that we dispute any allegation that our practices violated” federal anti-spam legal guidelines, Jenna Torluemke, senior public relations supervisor at Gen, stated in an electronic mail.

Commercial 5

Article content material

However privateness lawyer David Fraser says the CRTC wouldn’t have pursued an investigation and compliance settlement if it didn’t consider NLL broke the regulation.

“It’s fairly clear that the CRTC was of the view that this was in violation of our anti-spam regulation, and specifically, the spyware and adware set up of software program provisions within the anti-spam regulation,” stated Fraser, a lawyer at McInnes Cooper.

Within the settlement with the software program firm, the CRTC’s chief compliance and enforcement officer, Steven Harroun, famous the difficulty on the coronary heart of his investigation was if “NLL put in or prompted to be put in, in the midst of a business exercise, a pc program within the type of Norton Crypto on the pc methods of Canadian shoppers with out their consent” between July and December 2021.

Commercial 6

Article content material

It was solely in January 2022 that the corporate modified its set up course of for Norton 360 in order that it sought specific person consent for the set up of the cryptocurrency-mining laptop program.

Within the settlement, the CRTC’s chief enforcement officer famous the corporate was making an attempt to “tackle the difficulty posed by the shortage of specific consent for the set up of Norton Crypto… doubtless in response to issues raised by the general public.” He additionally acknowledged the change got here earlier than the regulator launched its investigation.

The corporate killed Norton Crypto in September and it’s no longed put in alongside Norton 360.

However as a part of its settlement with the CRTC, the corporate pledged to take “all affordable steps” to ensure all of the software program it sells and installs complies with Canada’s anti-spam legal guidelines. It additionally promised to designate a senior company workplace that might replace the corporate’s compliance program to make sure it displays Canadian regulation.

Commercial 7

Article content material

The corporate additionally pledged to not set up any packages on purchasers’ computer systems with out first acquiring specific consent or that may trigger the system to “function in a fashion opposite to the affordable expectations of the house owners.”

Fraser stated that is the primary time he has seen a well known model firm get dinged by the spyware and adware sections of federal anti-spam laws.

“I’m conscious of those sections having been used up to now, however principally to go after the true unhealthy actors, like botnets and issues that take over your laptop and switch it right into a spam machine within the background,” he stated.

“So this is likely to be somewhat bit extra eye-opening as a result of that is characterised as spyware and adware, and a number of corporations say, ‘hey I don’t do spyware and adware’. But it surely’s quite a bit broader that that.”


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a vigorous however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve got enabled electronic mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an electronic mail in case you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a person you comply with feedback. Go to our Group Tips for extra info and particulars on methods to regulate your electronic mail settings.

Be part of the Dialog